Do highway contracts usually end above the amount they were awarded at?
Usually. ANALYSIS
Of 3,026 finished CDOT construction contracts, 1,950 (64.4%) ended above the amount CDOT awarded them at. Another 1,075 (35.5%) ended below it. 1 ended exactly at its award. The middle contract grew by 3.27%, and 790 (26.1%) grew by more than 10%.
- Ended above the award 64.4%
- Ended below it 35.5%
Older contracts grew more often. Of contracts awarded from 1994 to 2009, 71.3% ended above the award. For 2010 to 2026 it was 59.4%. A recent contract that is already finished is more likely to be a short one. So this change shows a direction, not proof.
The test ANALYSIS
- What counts as finished. The newest pay estimate CDOT lists for the contract is marked final (FINL or FINAL). 3,028 contracts qualify. 2 print an amount of zero and are left out, which leaves 3,026.
- What is compared. The Award Project Amount against the Current Projected Amount. CDOT prints both on that final estimate.
- “Usually” means more than half ended above their award. 1,950 of 3,026 is 64.4%, which is more than half.
The numbers
| Figure | What it is, and how it is worked out |
|---|---|
| 3,026 CALC | Finished contracts compared= count of contracts whose newest estimate is final (3,028) − those with a zero amount (2) |
| 64.4% CALC | Share that ended above the award= 1,950 ÷ 3,026 |
| 35.5% CALC | Share that ended below the award= 1,075 ÷ 3,026; 1 more ended exactly at its award |
| 3.27% CALC | Growth of the middle contract= the middle of 3,026 values of (current amount − award) ÷ award |
| 26.1% CALC | Share that grew by more than 10%= 790 ÷ 3,026 |
| 71.3% CALC | Share above the award, awarded 1994 to 2009= 919 ÷ 1,289; the middle change was +5.00% |
| 59.4% CALC | Share above the award, awarded 2010 to 2026= 1,031 ÷ 1,737; the middle change was +2.06% |
- Records
- 4,424 pay estimates from CDOT’s index of . 9 were set aside because their own figures did not agree. The compared contracts were awarded from to .
- Sources
- How to reproduce
- Open CDOT’s pay-estimate index. For each contract, take the newest estimate, and keep it if it is marked FINL or FINAL and both amounts are above zero. Subtract the award from the current amount and divide by the award. Count the results above zero, below zero and above one tenth, and take the middle value.
- Limits
- Grew means the contract amount on the final estimate is above the award. The award is one contract’s starting amount, not a project’s budget, and this finding does not say why a contract changed.
- Dollars are never added across these three decades of contracts, because a dollar in one decade and a dollar in another are not the same amount.
- No contractor is named. This site does not store the names a pay estimate prints.